As I continue to read Wittgenstein's Poker, I wonder, why does anyone care about what happened along time ago, in England, in a small room, when a few philosophers had a tiff, huffed off, and, basically whatever. I had no answer to this " philosophical question" until I started to get into the backgrounds of Wittgenstein and Popper. Both, Austrian Jews during the Nazi takeover, both having similar friends and business associates, both living in the same area, both so different, but both so deeply affected by their early lives that it impacted their way of thinking and their star crossed relationship forever. Wittgenstein, born into an incomprehensibly wealth Jewish family, who converted for assimilation into the Viennese society, was, to cut to the chase, a true genius, but truly " disturbed". He could not find happiness or contentment, despite giving his vast sums to his sisters and teaching underprivileged kids. Then there was Popper. His family was also Jewish, his father a lawyer, and comfortable, in many of the social circles as Wittgenstein, but never as rich or connected. No one can claim that Popper was unintelligent by any means, but, he was like the step child of the Wittgenstein's. His family and he not as rich, intelligent, connected or special, but a player nonetheless. Wittgenstein and Popper were also extremely fortunate that they and their family were able to escape the death camps due to money, connections, luck and denial of heritage. I think, on some level, this denunciation of who they were ( Jewish) weighed on them. A conscious choice to change religion based on ones personal beliefs is quite different than changing to assimilate, fit in, be accepted, or, ultimately, not be persecuted or exterminated under Hitler's rule. Popper seemed to be an intelligent, deep thinker, but not nearly to the level of Wittgenstein. Wittgenstein, aside from all the money and connections, was a tortured genius, able to think on levels that Popper could only dream of. Wittgenstein had seemingly effortless ability to command a room and concept while Popper had a hard time getting people to listen or respect him (although he was quite respectable and intelligent) .
Monday, May 26, 2014
Book
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Ah, now you are finding some things.
ReplyDeleteThe book isn't about the fight, or the poker, it is about the men, the ideas.
So, what is Wittgenstien's philosophy about, and what is Poppers?
Also, realize that Karl Popper is one of the most influential philosophers of the 20th century!